News

La Comida nears deal for new location

Organization that provides nutrition program for seniors expects to finalize lease for near-term home

UPDATE: La Comida has announced an agreement with Stevenson House to move to south Palo Alto. Read more here.

After 45 years of offering nutritious meals to Palo Alto seniors of all nationalities, personalities and income levels, the nonprofit La Comida found itself facing scary prospect this summer: By the end of August, it may be homeless and in need.

The nonprofit, which has been operating in downtown since 1972, will have to move after its lease with the nonprofit Avenidas expires on Aug. 30. In September, Avenidas plans to kick off its long-planned renovation and expansion project – an $18-million endeavor that includes a new wellness center, fitness center and flexible classrooms and meeting rooms at its historic building at 450 Bryant St.

The project will also, however, result in a smaller dining room on the ground floor – a factor that last year created a rift between Palo Alto's primary senior-services provider and the popular nutrition program. In December, after months of back-and-forth negotiations and a formal appeal by La Comida against the Avenidas expansion, the two nonprofits reached an agreement to permanently part ways, with the understanding that Avenidas would help La Comida find a new location and offer transportation services.

Since then, La Comida has been on a desperate quest to secure new space: both in the near- and long-term. In June, members of the board announced publicly that they had a very strong lead on a location that can accommodate the program immediately after this summer. On June 27, Davina Brown, vice president of the La Comida board of directors, told the council that her organization has had some "very, very good meetings" and that things look "a lot more promising" than they had before.

Help sustain the local news you depend on.

Your contribution matters. Become a member today.

Join

Now, things are looking slightly better. Bill Blodgett, chair of the La Comida board, told the Weekly on Wednesday that his group will be making an announcement within the next few days about a new short-term home.

Blodgett declined to say where the new location is, pending the completion of the agreement. And while he said the organization is pleased by the new development, he noted that the new home will be away from downtown. To make things easier for its users, the organization is looking for a second serving location that would be closer to downtown, he said, though that location probably won't be available for some time after the first location opens.

"Our hope is that this agreement would carry us over until we're able to establish a longer-term presence, hopefully back in the downtown area," Blodgett said.

The potential agreement for a near-term home is a bit of bright news after months of anxiety for La Comida officials and longtime users, some of whom have been attending recent council meetings and calling for the city to get more involved in helping the nonprofit find a new home.

Gale Fullerton, 74, said he has been coming to La Comida for 15 years. He lauded the organization for providing food to everyone, "from wealthy people to those who are homeless."

Stay informed

Get the latest local news and information sent straight to your inbox.

Stay informed

Get the latest local news and information sent straight to your inbox.

"This is where they get their only food of the day, and it's their only social activity,” Fullerton told the council on June 19. "Social activity is extremely important."

La Comida's faltering prospects for finding a long-term home, coupled with residents' anxiety over losing a popular nutrition program, has also created a new push for a reunion between Avenidas and La Comida. In early June, the council received a petition signed by 234 people (an additional 225 had signed the online version), calling for La Comida's preservation as a "permanent partner" with Avenidas. The petition included a data about La Comida's customers, 91 percent of whom are over 65 years old and 31 percent of whom are over 80.

The petition also points out that 42 percent identify themselves as low income; 30 percent live alone; 46 percent consider the La Comida experience as their "primary meal"; and more than 30 percent rely on bus transportation.

The petition notes that while a possible short-term location has been identified, this location is smaller than ideal. In the downtown area, no location of adequate size had been identified for either the short- or long-term.

"Ideally, La Comida would return to downtown Palo Alto, co-located with, or close to Avenidas, after its renovation and expansion, to keep the Senior Nutrition Program in close proximity to other senior services," the petition states. "La Comida is more than getting a meal for many of these patrons. It offers a place for many seniors to meet friends and it is a purpose for many seniors to keep moving around as they help and volunteer at La Comida."

Most Viewed Stories

Most Viewed Stories

For City Council members Tom DuBois and Lydia Kou, the diners' request makes perfect sense. Both have been working with La Comida to try to find a new home and both believe that the new Avenidas would be uniquely suited to housing a senior-nutrition program.

"Those services belong together," DuBois said in a recent interview. "It just doesn't make sense to have senior services in one place and nutrition services somewhere else."

Kou, who had volunteered at La Comida, noted that the nonprofit has been "looking very, very diligently" for a new space but has not had success. She noted that Avenidas has not yet broken ground, which means the organization can still "redraw" its plans to support La Comida's needs.

"Given that this is a city property and that we do have obligation to all seniors – it should be still considered as a place to house La Comida," Kou told the Weekly, referring to the historic building at 450 Bryant that Avenidas leases for $1 per year.

Even if a redesign seems highly unlikely (the Avenidas project won the city's approval last fall after more than a year of public hearings and a multitude of revisions), Kou said she believes there's still room for discussion between the two nonprofits about what it would take to accommodate La Comida's needs.

DuBois agreed and noted that Avenidas can come up with a flexible plan that spreads out diners over a larger space, with different areas earmarked for dining, having tea or simply mingling. This could allow the senior-nutrition program to function with a smaller dining area.

DuBois said he believes there are some "hurt feelings and egos on both sides." But given La Comida's precarious situation and Avenidas' commitment to local seniors, he said, he believes these issues can be resolved.

"La Comida went out and tested the market," DuBois said in a recent interview. "They realize now how hard it is to find space and I think they're willing to compromise.

"We hope Avenidas is also willing to compromise."

To be sure, any reunification would require a renewed spirit of compromise. Last year, the two nonprofits sparred over Avenidas' plans to reduce the dining area by between more than 30 seats to accommodate both building codes and the new design. They ultimately went into mediation, which La Comida officials said reaffirmed their belief that the new dining area would be suboptimal for the nonprofit's needs.

Now, the two nonprofits are once again considering this option. Amy Andonian, CEO and president of Avenidas, said her organization "has been meeting regularly with the City and with La Comida to develop a long term solution."

"Both parties may return to mediation in the near future," Andonian told the Weekly.

Blodgett noted that despite the recent disagreements, La Comida and Avenidas have had "an excellent partnership over the years." While he declined to discuss the potential for mediation, he said his organization and Avenidas continue to "cooperate effectively" through this transition period.

"We still have common goals in mind: providing what's best for seniors," Blodgett said.

Related content:

Behind the Headlines: Preserving La Comida

Craving a new voice in Peninsula dining?

Sign up for the Peninsula Foodist newsletter.

Sign up now
Gennady Sheyner
 
Gennady Sheyner covers the City Hall beat in Palo Alto as well as regional politics, with a special focus on housing and transportation. Before joining the Palo Alto Weekly/PaloAltoOnline.com in 2008, he covered breaking news and local politics for the Waterbury Republican-American, a daily newspaper in Connecticut. Read more >>

Follow on Twitter @paloaltoweekly, Facebook and on Instagram @paloaltoonline for breaking news, local events, photos, videos and more.

La Comida nears deal for new location

Organization that provides nutrition program for seniors expects to finalize lease for near-term home

UPDATE: La Comida has announced an agreement with Stevenson House to move to south Palo Alto. Read more here.

After 45 years of offering nutritious meals to Palo Alto seniors of all nationalities, personalities and income levels, the nonprofit La Comida found itself facing scary prospect this summer: By the end of August, it may be homeless and in need.

The nonprofit, which has been operating in downtown since 1972, will have to move after its lease with the nonprofit Avenidas expires on Aug. 30. In September, Avenidas plans to kick off its long-planned renovation and expansion project – an $18-million endeavor that includes a new wellness center, fitness center and flexible classrooms and meeting rooms at its historic building at 450 Bryant St.

The project will also, however, result in a smaller dining room on the ground floor – a factor that last year created a rift between Palo Alto's primary senior-services provider and the popular nutrition program. In December, after months of back-and-forth negotiations and a formal appeal by La Comida against the Avenidas expansion, the two nonprofits reached an agreement to permanently part ways, with the understanding that Avenidas would help La Comida find a new location and offer transportation services.

Since then, La Comida has been on a desperate quest to secure new space: both in the near- and long-term. In June, members of the board announced publicly that they had a very strong lead on a location that can accommodate the program immediately after this summer. On June 27, Davina Brown, vice president of the La Comida board of directors, told the council that her organization has had some "very, very good meetings" and that things look "a lot more promising" than they had before.

Now, things are looking slightly better. Bill Blodgett, chair of the La Comida board, told the Weekly on Wednesday that his group will be making an announcement within the next few days about a new short-term home.

Blodgett declined to say where the new location is, pending the completion of the agreement. And while he said the organization is pleased by the new development, he noted that the new home will be away from downtown. To make things easier for its users, the organization is looking for a second serving location that would be closer to downtown, he said, though that location probably won't be available for some time after the first location opens.

"Our hope is that this agreement would carry us over until we're able to establish a longer-term presence, hopefully back in the downtown area," Blodgett said.

The potential agreement for a near-term home is a bit of bright news after months of anxiety for La Comida officials and longtime users, some of whom have been attending recent council meetings and calling for the city to get more involved in helping the nonprofit find a new home.

Gale Fullerton, 74, said he has been coming to La Comida for 15 years. He lauded the organization for providing food to everyone, "from wealthy people to those who are homeless."

"This is where they get their only food of the day, and it's their only social activity,” Fullerton told the council on June 19. "Social activity is extremely important."

La Comida's faltering prospects for finding a long-term home, coupled with residents' anxiety over losing a popular nutrition program, has also created a new push for a reunion between Avenidas and La Comida. In early June, the council received a petition signed by 234 people (an additional 225 had signed the online version), calling for La Comida's preservation as a "permanent partner" with Avenidas. The petition included a data about La Comida's customers, 91 percent of whom are over 65 years old and 31 percent of whom are over 80.

The petition also points out that 42 percent identify themselves as low income; 30 percent live alone; 46 percent consider the La Comida experience as their "primary meal"; and more than 30 percent rely on bus transportation.

The petition notes that while a possible short-term location has been identified, this location is smaller than ideal. In the downtown area, no location of adequate size had been identified for either the short- or long-term.

"Ideally, La Comida would return to downtown Palo Alto, co-located with, or close to Avenidas, after its renovation and expansion, to keep the Senior Nutrition Program in close proximity to other senior services," the petition states. "La Comida is more than getting a meal for many of these patrons. It offers a place for many seniors to meet friends and it is a purpose for many seniors to keep moving around as they help and volunteer at La Comida."

For City Council members Tom DuBois and Lydia Kou, the diners' request makes perfect sense. Both have been working with La Comida to try to find a new home and both believe that the new Avenidas would be uniquely suited to housing a senior-nutrition program.

"Those services belong together," DuBois said in a recent interview. "It just doesn't make sense to have senior services in one place and nutrition services somewhere else."

Kou, who had volunteered at La Comida, noted that the nonprofit has been "looking very, very diligently" for a new space but has not had success. She noted that Avenidas has not yet broken ground, which means the organization can still "redraw" its plans to support La Comida's needs.

"Given that this is a city property and that we do have obligation to all seniors – it should be still considered as a place to house La Comida," Kou told the Weekly, referring to the historic building at 450 Bryant that Avenidas leases for $1 per year.

Even if a redesign seems highly unlikely (the Avenidas project won the city's approval last fall after more than a year of public hearings and a multitude of revisions), Kou said she believes there's still room for discussion between the two nonprofits about what it would take to accommodate La Comida's needs.

DuBois agreed and noted that Avenidas can come up with a flexible plan that spreads out diners over a larger space, with different areas earmarked for dining, having tea or simply mingling. This could allow the senior-nutrition program to function with a smaller dining area.

DuBois said he believes there are some "hurt feelings and egos on both sides." But given La Comida's precarious situation and Avenidas' commitment to local seniors, he said, he believes these issues can be resolved.

"La Comida went out and tested the market," DuBois said in a recent interview. "They realize now how hard it is to find space and I think they're willing to compromise.

"We hope Avenidas is also willing to compromise."

To be sure, any reunification would require a renewed spirit of compromise. Last year, the two nonprofits sparred over Avenidas' plans to reduce the dining area by between more than 30 seats to accommodate both building codes and the new design. They ultimately went into mediation, which La Comida officials said reaffirmed their belief that the new dining area would be suboptimal for the nonprofit's needs.

Now, the two nonprofits are once again considering this option. Amy Andonian, CEO and president of Avenidas, said her organization "has been meeting regularly with the City and with La Comida to develop a long term solution."

"Both parties may return to mediation in the near future," Andonian told the Weekly.

Blodgett noted that despite the recent disagreements, La Comida and Avenidas have had "an excellent partnership over the years." While he declined to discuss the potential for mediation, he said his organization and Avenidas continue to "cooperate effectively" through this transition period.

"We still have common goals in mind: providing what's best for seniors," Blodgett said.

Related content:

Behind the Headlines: Preserving La Comida

Comments

Marie
Registered user
Midtown
on Jul 6, 2017 at 11:50 am
Marie, Midtown
Registered user
on Jul 6, 2017 at 11:50 am

I fully support Avenidas cosharing with La Comida. As a member of Avenidas, I was shocked when I found their design would reduce the dining area, essentially kicking out La Comida. I opposed the expansion for this reason, not that anyone at Avenidas cared. I think they have lost their original mission and have developed an "edifice" complex. Having a shiny new building and offices for the administrative staff is more important that serving low income seniors. Their new goal seems to focus more on providing services to middle/high income seniors, rather than lower income seniors. I'm willing to bet that the new fitness space will either require additional fees, or the Avenidas membership fee will increase drastically. So far, there has been no information on what the new fee structure will look like. However, over the years, I have seen fewer and fewer "free" benefits for Avenidas members and more and more classes that give a minor discounts to members.

It looks to me that running Avenidas as a private nonprofit, financially supported by the city of Palo Alto may be a mistake. Both the Los Altos and Menlo Park's senior center is run by the city administration. Maybe it is time for Palo Alto to reclaim the city's building, rented to Avenidas for $1 per year, and operate a senior center for all seniors, not just rich ones. Alternatively, they can include a senior center in the new plans for Cubberley, and charge a market rent for Avenidas when the lease comes up for renewal (alas, not until 2027 per paloaltocityca.iqm2.com/Citizens/FileOpen.aspx?Type=30&ID=4405). This seems similar to the situation with the Junior Museum, long free to anyone, which after a major remodel paid for by rich donors, will charge a "nominal" $20 (1 adult 2 kids admission). That is nominal only to the 1%, especially since most usage is only for a couple hours.

In any case, I used to donate to Avenidas. No more, unless they find away to accommodate La Comida in their remodeled facility and again show tangible support for local low income seniors. They have lost their way.


Compassionate Observer
Los Altos
on Jul 6, 2017 at 12:14 pm
Compassionate Observer, Los Altos
on Jul 6, 2017 at 12:14 pm

Though I am a "Senior" (That term has often annoyed me in its trite connotations!) and have long used and appreciated Avenidas for it's offerings and outlook. I have especially been impressed with it's respect and outreach toward the group of those who are lonely and challenged economically in down town Palo Alto.

Mornings the coffee area provides a casual unobtrusive place for reading the paper and perhaps visiting with those passing by. (Or getting warm in Winter)
Before the noon hour the people patiently waiting for La Comida to open have a place to "be".
Last week while waiting in the lobby for my class to begin, I spoke to a man seated near me, noting his friendly greeting by name, to many who passed by. He said simply in response. "Well you see I'm lonely, live in one room, and this is where I have contact with others." He was not complaining, just stating fact.

It was shocking to me when someone I asked about the renovation told me that Avenidas is wanting to attract those younger(Baby Boomer Generation) entering the older years, and for them it is necessary to upgrade the facilities to enhance their possibilities of joining." My question is ""What will thus being lost here?"

I was also told at the desk that it was La Comida who decided to leave! I did respond to that statement considering that it was a bit more complicated than that - with their downsizing prospects as part of it.

I am encouraged by reading today that negotiations are again taking place between the "bruised egos" of each group.
An upgraded, "with it" Silicon Valley Facility should not the main priority while forgetting those who need the comfort and strength of purpose that has always existed at Avenidas no matter what their means.


Avenidas' priorities are disappointing
Another Palo Alto neighborhood
on Jul 6, 2017 at 1:29 pm
Avenidas' priorities are disappointing, Another Palo Alto neighborhood
on Jul 6, 2017 at 1:29 pm

I am disappointed in Avenidas' priorities, and I hope City Council is paying attention to the values underneath these choices when they consider what organizations to support. I am glad to hear that La Comida is on the verge of finding a new location for their important service.

I am an aging baby boomer who will not be joining Avenidas. I think feeding meals to the needy should be prioritized over luxury fitness and computer facilities for more well-heeled seniors. I walk and ride a bike and I lift weights at home. Exercise is easy and cheap. People who NEED community and good nutrition should be better treated.


anon
Another Palo Alto neighborhood
on Jul 6, 2017 at 1:38 pm
anon, Another Palo Alto neighborhood
on Jul 6, 2017 at 1:38 pm

I am shocked at Avinidas letting this go this far. La Comida services are as fundamental as it gets - food and human interaction. There is nothing Avinidas provides in its place that is more important or vital. Nothing. There is no use of the former space that served diners that is as important. The City really dropped the ball when it approved the remodel plans that allowed Avinidas to get away with this.
That said, there better be no more barriers in the way of the temporary solution. If anyone at this new venue has a complaint, they simply must not understand what is at stake, or they don't care beyond their own selves. Sad.
I hope this works out short term and long, and that Avinidas steps up and repairs its very tarnished reputation by making additional room long term.


anon
Another Palo Alto neighborhood
on Jul 6, 2017 at 1:39 pm
anon, Another Palo Alto neighborhood
on Jul 6, 2017 at 1:39 pm

And thank you Council members DuBois and Kou for working on this to help resolve it.


Robert Smith
Duveneck/St. Francis
on Jul 6, 2017 at 2:45 pm
Robert Smith, Duveneck/St. Francis
on Jul 6, 2017 at 2:45 pm

From what I know about services to this demographic, food service is the tent poll for an organization such as Avenidas. Moving the food service to a different location is logistically difficult and cannot help either organization.

I know little about this beyond what I have read in the papers over the years, but it seems to me that a problem has developed between Avenidas and La Comita. Avenidas is using its advantage to get rid of La Comita, without regard to their customers. They are being designed out of the plan, and the city is paying for it. Just a guess.

The city--we taxpayers--are funding a lot of this. The city needs to exercise due diligence and see what the customers want, and then have a talking to Avenidas and La Comita about their mutual obligations.

If not, it may be time for the city to stop supporting Avenidas and find a better way to use their our scarce tax dollars.




Corkey
Crescent Park
on Jul 6, 2017 at 2:56 pm
Corkey, Crescent Park
on Jul 6, 2017 at 2:56 pm

It is an enlightened and compassionate approach to any polarizing solution to step back, re-asses and be willing to find the way to win / win rather than smug victory. The later is a shallow foundation to build an all embracing healthy community.


sf
Midtown
on Jul 6, 2017 at 5:06 pm
sf, Midtown
on Jul 6, 2017 at 5:06 pm

Remember this situation when the planning for upgrades to the Cubberley Community Center gets going. I believe at one point Avenidas wanted the entire center for senior services. My point being, future services should take into account ALL residents, including the oft-neglected non-youth, non-teen, non-senior section.


Novelera
Registered user
Midtown
on Jul 6, 2017 at 5:43 pm
Novelera, Midtown
Registered user
on Jul 6, 2017 at 5:43 pm

Thank you Tom and Lydia for becoming involved and hopefully brokering a solution that will keep La Comida where it's always been.


Chris Gaither
Mayfield
on Jul 6, 2017 at 6:06 pm
Chris Gaither, Mayfield
on Jul 6, 2017 at 6:06 pm

As a La Comida board member, Thank You Gennady for the well written article with the correct facts. Very well done! And, thank you to Lydia and Tom for stepping up, and helping La Comida as City of Palo Alto representatives.


Move Avenidas and La Comida to Cubberly
Embarcadero Oaks/Leland
on Jul 6, 2017 at 6:52 pm
Move Avenidas and La Comida to Cubberly, Embarcadero Oaks/Leland
on Jul 6, 2017 at 6:52 pm

Cubberly is a better location for Senior services than Downtown. Run the shuttle from the Bryant location for people who walk. For those who drive, the lot at Cubberley is bigger an WAY easier to get to and park in than downtown. Repurpose the downtown building. The current renovation proposal is an inappropriate use of public funds.


Political correctness
Downtown North
on Jul 6, 2017 at 9:26 pm
Political correctness, Downtown North
on Jul 6, 2017 at 9:26 pm

There is an elephant in the room that is awkward to mention.
That is, that the lunch audience is largely Asian. Not 100% of course but the overwhelming majority.

Since some of these folks are multi-millionaires - just look in every day's newspaper to see who is paying 3 to 4 Million dollars and more, for a house - somehow the Asian community needs to supply its elders with a comfortable place for lunch and socializing. Many at the lunch don't speak English so there is minimal exchange with English speakers.

I think this may be an unspoken problem that needs to be addressed. Political correctness sometimes prevents seeing what is right in front of us.


Resident
Charleston Gardens
on Jul 6, 2017 at 9:38 pm
Resident, Charleston Gardens
on Jul 6, 2017 at 9:38 pm

Relative's of the super rich and for that matter super tight.


HOPE
another community
on Jul 7, 2017 at 11:22 am
HOPE, another community
on Jul 7, 2017 at 11:22 am

TO BE OR NOT TO BE!
THIS IS THE ?
AND THE ANSWER "TO BE".
FOOD AND CONGREGATING AND FEEDING AND BLESSINGS ARE A NECESSITY FOR ALL.
AVENIDAS NEEDS THE ENVIRONMENT OF THE NEEDY COMMUNITY TO BLEND AND CONNECT .
THERE ARE SMILES AND CHEERS WAITING FOR POSITIVE RESULTS WITH A RESOU NDING YES,,,********WE ARE HERE FOR ALL,,,WITH GRATEFULNESS AND HAND CLAPPING!


Don't miss out on the discussion!
Sign up to be notified of new comments on this topic.

Post a comment

On Wednesday, we'll be launching a new website. To prepare and make sure all our content is available on the new platform, commenting on stories and in TownSquare has been disabled. When the new site is online, past comments will be available to be seen and we'll reinstate the ability to comment. We appreciate your patience while we make this transition.