News

Neighbors call on Stanford to remove trees after man died from tree that fell on university-owned land

Jesus Ivan Cruz Diaz was killed by a downed eucalyptus on March 21

Ladera and Portola Valley residents are asking Stanford University to better manage its eucalyptus trees along Alpine Road near Interstate Highway 280 after a San Jose man was killed last week when one of the trees fell on his work van.

Another tree fell on the same stretch of roadway on Monday, March 27, according to photos sent from Ladera residents, shutting down Alpine Road while it was removed. Resident Carol Espinosa said she wants to reduce the chance of another death or property damage caused by unstable trees along Los Trancos Creek.

This news organization has reached out to the California Highway Patrol for more details on the incident on Monday.

"It's not something that is going to stop soon," said Espinosa, who's lived in Ladera for about 50 years.

She also noted that Alpine Road, which provides access to Highway 280, is a major emergency exit point from Portola Valley and it can take an extra 20 minutes or so to leave town if you can't use Alpine Road.

Help sustain the local news you depend on.

Your contribution matters. Become a member today.

Join

Ladera resident Briana Fortnam said in an email that the trees coming down is frightening because the Alpine corridor is a main thoroughfare for many residents in Portola Valley, Ladera and beyond.

"Stanford should assess the health of each tree on their property along the Alpine corridor," she said in a March 27 email. "As you can see from the photos, the tree that fell this morning was adjacent to the tree that killed Jesus Cruz last week. Stanford was asked to assess the health of these trees when the first tree fell and killed a man last Tuesday. We have not yet heard of any action taken to review the danger posed by these trees."

Jesus Ivan Cruz Diaz, 29, who died Tuesday, March 21, had just completed a job for Able Plumbing, Sewer and Drain when a tree fell on his work van as he drove east along Alpine Road near the Highway 280 south on-ramp. Emergency responders said that several more trees fell while they were attempting to extricate Diaz from the van, nearly hitting them and their vehicles.

"We are very saddened by the tragic loss of life that happened as a result of last week's storm," said Luisa Rapport, director of Emergency Communications and Media Relations for Stanford. "The university has performed an initial review of the trees on Stanford land adjacent to the three trees that have already fallen. The trees are very challenging to reach for tree crews due to the saturated soil, distance from the street, and size of the trees. Stanford is reaching out to well-equipped service providers to better understand the logistics of removing hazardous tree conditions."

Stanford is in contact with county officials to share updates and coordinate work in the area, she said. San Mateo County is working with the CHP to place cones and detour signs restricting access to the lane closest to the creek on Alpine Road, she said.

Stanford's land maps confirm that the university owns the land in question. Stanford's 8,180 acres of contiguous land in the area are in six different governmental jurisdictions.

Stanford University-owned land in the Palo Alto area. Courtesy Stanford University.

Espinosa contacted Santa Clara County Supervisor Joe Simitian on Monday, March 27, who reached out to Stanford and the Santa Clara County Planning Department. Simitian said he plans to raise the issue at the county's board meeting next week, as well as contact San Mateo County since there are a "range of views" about which county the site is located in.

"Anyone who has been through a tree removal in either county, it can be an extended and time-consuming process," Simitian said. In an emergency circumstance like this, the process needs to move faster, he said.

Stay informed

Get the latest local news and information sent straight to your inbox.

Stay informed

Get the latest local news and information sent straight to your inbox.

Angela Swartz
 
Angela Swartz joined The Almanac in 2018 and covers education and small towns. She has a background covering education, city politics and business. Read more >>

Follow on Twitter @paloaltoweekly, Facebook and on Instagram @paloaltoonline for breaking news, local events, photos, videos and more.

Neighbors call on Stanford to remove trees after man died from tree that fell on university-owned land

Jesus Ivan Cruz Diaz was killed by a downed eucalyptus on March 21

Ladera and Portola Valley residents are asking Stanford University to better manage its eucalyptus trees along Alpine Road near Interstate Highway 280 after a San Jose man was killed last week when one of the trees fell on his work van.

Another tree fell on the same stretch of roadway on Monday, March 27, according to photos sent from Ladera residents, shutting down Alpine Road while it was removed. Resident Carol Espinosa said she wants to reduce the chance of another death or property damage caused by unstable trees along Los Trancos Creek.

This news organization has reached out to the California Highway Patrol for more details on the incident on Monday.

"It's not something that is going to stop soon," said Espinosa, who's lived in Ladera for about 50 years.

She also noted that Alpine Road, which provides access to Highway 280, is a major emergency exit point from Portola Valley and it can take an extra 20 minutes or so to leave town if you can't use Alpine Road.

Ladera resident Briana Fortnam said in an email that the trees coming down is frightening because the Alpine corridor is a main thoroughfare for many residents in Portola Valley, Ladera and beyond.

"Stanford should assess the health of each tree on their property along the Alpine corridor," she said in a March 27 email. "As you can see from the photos, the tree that fell this morning was adjacent to the tree that killed Jesus Cruz last week. Stanford was asked to assess the health of these trees when the first tree fell and killed a man last Tuesday. We have not yet heard of any action taken to review the danger posed by these trees."

Jesus Ivan Cruz Diaz, 29, who died Tuesday, March 21, had just completed a job for Able Plumbing, Sewer and Drain when a tree fell on his work van as he drove east along Alpine Road near the Highway 280 south on-ramp. Emergency responders said that several more trees fell while they were attempting to extricate Diaz from the van, nearly hitting them and their vehicles.

"We are very saddened by the tragic loss of life that happened as a result of last week's storm," said Luisa Rapport, director of Emergency Communications and Media Relations for Stanford. "The university has performed an initial review of the trees on Stanford land adjacent to the three trees that have already fallen. The trees are very challenging to reach for tree crews due to the saturated soil, distance from the street, and size of the trees. Stanford is reaching out to well-equipped service providers to better understand the logistics of removing hazardous tree conditions."

Stanford is in contact with county officials to share updates and coordinate work in the area, she said. San Mateo County is working with the CHP to place cones and detour signs restricting access to the lane closest to the creek on Alpine Road, she said.

Stanford's land maps confirm that the university owns the land in question. Stanford's 8,180 acres of contiguous land in the area are in six different governmental jurisdictions.

Espinosa contacted Santa Clara County Supervisor Joe Simitian on Monday, March 27, who reached out to Stanford and the Santa Clara County Planning Department. Simitian said he plans to raise the issue at the county's board meeting next week, as well as contact San Mateo County since there are a "range of views" about which county the site is located in.

"Anyone who has been through a tree removal in either county, it can be an extended and time-consuming process," Simitian said. In an emergency circumstance like this, the process needs to move faster, he said.

Comments

Gary
Registered user
South of Midtown
on Mar 29, 2023 at 10:40 am
Gary, South of Midtown
Registered user
on Mar 29, 2023 at 10:40 am

Stanford University needs to clear-cut the trees (200 feet) along the road.
These trees were planted in an ill-advised lumber project.


Online Name
Registered user
Embarcadero Oaks/Leland
on Mar 29, 2023 at 11:33 am
Online Name, Embarcadero Oaks/Leland
Registered user
on Mar 29, 2023 at 11:33 am

Why do we think Stanford will suddenly start worrying about people's safety and/or property damage given its very long history of ignoring complaints about its dead, dying and diseased trees along Alpine Road, in Stanford Weekend Acres and in College Terrace?


Anonymous
Registered user
Duveneck/St. Francis
on Mar 29, 2023 at 1:35 pm
Anonymous, Duveneck/St. Francis
Registered user
on Mar 29, 2023 at 1:35 pm

This will be a test of local/regional government action/efficiency (or not).
- Will Stanford act meaningfully if/when two adjacent counties (hopefully) request or require speedy action on these trees for the safety of constituents and visitors.
Very sorry for the death by roadside treefall of the plumber driving by, going about his routine business.
Let’s NOT make this similar to the San Francisquito Creek remediation/improvement - which action is also needed now on bridges, with vital Stanford action upstream - not decades later.


Amy
Registered user
Crescent Park
on Mar 30, 2023 at 4:35 pm
Amy , Crescent Park
Registered user
on Mar 30, 2023 at 4:35 pm

About 13 years ago my neighbors and I had a years long fight with the City to remove 16 aged, improperly maintained eucalyptus trees that encircled the Pardee Park playground. Not indigenous to CA (brought here around 1820 by an Australian) they have shallow roots, drop limbs as needed when not getting enough water and in the case of these ones were rotted on the inside due to improper pruning. Those trees grow quickly and initially people thought the wood would be good for railroad ties but proved to be too brittle. Now we have them all over the place and many many of them are not safe. My friend got her car smashed flat by a falling eucalyptus a few years ago and just today I noticed one down on its side near the vacant lot off of Palm Drive where people tailgate. Not great trees.


Don't miss out on the discussion!
Sign up to be notified of new comments on this topic.

Post a comment

On Wednesday, we'll be launching a new website. To prepare and make sure all our content is available on the new platform, commenting on stories and in TownSquare has been disabled. When the new site is online, past comments will be available to be seen and we'll reinstate the ability to comment. We appreciate your patience while we make this transition.