Nirit Hazan grew up in Nahal Oz, an Israeli kibbutz about 700 yards from the Gaza Strip border, and when she first got word last Friday night, Oct. 6, that Hamas militants had infiltrated the Gaza border, she felt sick to her stomach and thought that her worst childhood nightmare was coming to life.
Hazan now works at Stanford University and lives in Cupertino, but she thought of her 86-year-old mother, Tami Halevy, who still lives at Nahal Oz. In what she called "the most surreal and horrific day" of her life, Hazan urged her mother to go into her mamad, a secured room akin to a bomb shelter.
When Halevy got there, she remained in touch with Hazan and her four siblings over WhatsApp, reporting about the gunshots close to her home and asking for news. Hazan also learned that her mother is unable to lock the mamad.
"The thought of her sheltering in place all by herself in an unlocked mamad while terrorists are roaming her beautiful kibbutz, going from house to house, looking to murder innocent civilians and taking others, including children and women as prisoners of war, was something beyond our darkest and wildest imagination," Hazan said at an Oct. 10 event at the Oshman Family Jewish Community Center (JCC) in Palo Alto.
Over the coming hours, the nightmare unfolded along the border as other kibbutzim were targeted with rockets or excursions. Finally, about 17 hours after the attack began, a group of Israeli commandos arrived to evacuate Halevy, allowing her to get to a bus that took her to another daughter's house in Jerusalem, Hazan said.
"The trauma that she endured is unimaginable, and yet we feel blessed that she is alive," Hazan said, before listing the names of various friends and neighbors and who lost their lives or were abducted.
Hazan was one of hundreds of people at the JCC who were personally touched by the broiling conflict, which began on Oct. 7 when Hamas crossed the Gaza Strip border and targeted Israeli villages in a sweeping and shocking strike that resulted in more than 1,000 people getting killed and dozens kidnapped, according to the Associated Press.
The suffering has since grown more widespread as the Israeli military reacted by pummeling the Gaza Strip with airstrikes that have killed about 800 people and wounded thousands more, according to the AP.
"No one is untouched by this," said Zack Bodner, president and CEO of the Oshman Family JCC. "No one in our community is untouched by this tragedy."
When he heard about the attack on Saturday morning, Bodner felt terrified, then enraged, then dumbfounded and then heartbroken, he said. As he saw videos of the attack play over and over again on the news, his emotions ran like a rollercoaster. He reached out to his cousin in Israel and held his breath waiting for response, he said.
"When they finally responded, I exhaled and immediately afterward I felt this sense of guilt because I knew that others can't exhale," Bodner told an estimated crowd of about 2,000 people who came to the JCC.
He listed the names of people he knows: the 16-year-old student in the local community whose Israeli soccer coach was killed in the attack; the man whose two daughters were called up to serve in the attack's aftermath; the Israeli tour guide whose building was hit and destroyed by a missile early in the attack.
"He feels lucky to be a war refugee because he knows a couple that was killed and others who were taken," he said.
Religious leaders, politicians and residents from throughout the Peninsula came to Tuesday's solidarity event. They waved flags, sang songs, held memorial candles and prayed for Israel and for the victims of the war.
Though they were thousands of miles away from the conflict, for many the event hit close to home. Hundreds of hands went up when attendees were asked if they have friends or family members who were called up by the Israeli army.
Assembly member Marc Berman, who took trips to Israel with a group of Sacramento colleagues in 2018 and 2019, recalled the meetings he held with Israeli and Palestinian residents in places like Nahal Oz and the West Bank.
Berman, D-Menlo Park, said his mother's cousin currently lives in Israel. Three of her four sons were called up to serve in the military along with 300,000 other reservists after the Saturday attack, he said.
On Sunday, the cousin attended a funeral for a friend's son, who was killed while rescuing families on the Gaza border. During the funeral, sirens rang out, indicating another rocket attack, and guests were forced to lie on the ground and wait, their bodies overlapping and their hands covering their heads.
Berman said seeing the atrocities that have been occurring in Israel since Oct. 7 both made him sad and filled him with rage. But even amidst the chaos, his cousin said the entire country is volunteering and looking for ways to help.
"As she put it, 'The solidarity is palpable — a balm after all the contentious political rifts,'" Berman said, alluding to recent tensions between Israeli political factions over a contentious plan by Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu to overhaul the nation's judicial system.
Berman said he has taken solace in the high number of colleagues, both liberal Democrats and conservative Republicans, who have reached out and made statements in support of Israel. Berman said his conversations in Israel residents during the two trips have taught him about the complicated political dynamics in the region.
"But what is not complicated and what all of these colleagues have expressed to me personally is that they stand in strong solidarity with Israel and that they know the responsibility for these atrocities lies solely with Hamas," Berman said.
There have been times in the past when others have tried to destroy the Jewish community, he said.
"We have gotten stronger and we have thrived," Berman said. "This time will be no different."
Like Berman, State Sen. Josh Becker said he had spent Saturday morning trying to come to terms with the "horror and brutality" of the Hamas attack. Becker, who has cousins, nieces and nephews in Israel, currently serves as vice chair of the 14-member California Legislative Jewish Caucus. He said he was heartened by the support he has received from his colleagues in the Latino, African-American, the Asian-American and LGBTQ caucuses since the Oct. 7 attack on Israel.
"They all stand with us right now in this fight," Becker said.
The struggle in Israel will be long and difficult, Becker said. He encouraged attendees to do their part by using their voices, networks and social media accounts to fight disinformation and hate and to support Israel.
"It's OK to grieve. It's OK to feel pain. It's OK to shed tears. I've done all of the above in the last few days," Becker said. "But what is not OK is to stay in that pain. We must persist. We must lean on our collective strength, the strength of our community, to be here for our local Israeli community and to take action."
The Oct. 7 attacks have drawn a mix of responses in local communities, with some residents using the occasion of Hamas strikes on Israeli civilians as an opportunity to voice their support for Palestine and their opposition to Israeli occupation of the West Bank, Gaza Strip and Golan Heights.
On Oct. 8, hundreds marched in downtown San Francisco and chanted, "Palestine will be free!," according to NBC News footage. At one point, the demonstrators took their protest to the Israeli Consul General's office, according to the news report.
In Palo Alto, however, the sentiment on Oct. 10 was entirely pro-Israel. Marco Sermoneto, consul general of Israel to the Pacific Northwest, drew cheers when he talked about the need to support Israel and defeat Hamas, a militant group that has been in power in Gaza since 2006.
"Hamas will soon understand that by attacking us they have made a mistake of historic proportions," Sermoneto said. "We may have paid a heavy price but the price they will pay will be unbearable and it will be remembered by all of Israel's enemies for a long time."
Comments
Registered user
Crescent Park
on Oct 11, 2023 at 2:04 pm
Registered user
on Oct 11, 2023 at 2:04 pm
My heart is breaking from the horrible massacres conducted by Hamas in Israel and now yet another arial massacre by Israel in Gaza. The jailbreak by Hamas from the Gaza prison camp was conducted in an appalling manner. But the cycle of violence, originating with the Zionist attack on the Palestinians in 1948 and the violent expulsion from their homes and lands will not be broken by yet another slaughter of innocent Palestinians from the air. Peace can only be achieved by redressing the theft of Palestinian lands and granting full equality to all residents of Israel/Palestine
In Gaza, 70% of the two million residents are refugees or descendants of refugees ethnically cleansed from their lands by Zionist militias in 1948. For 75 years they have been denied their right of return guaranteed all refugees by the Geneva Convention. [Portion removed.]
Yes, I am mourning the hundreds of senseless Israeli deaths and hope none of my friends are among them. But I do not stand with [portion removed] Israel as it, yet again, rains terror, death and destruction upon two million essentially defenseless Palestinian men, women and children trapped in the world’s largest open air prison built by Israel.
Registered user
Midtown
on Oct 11, 2023 at 4:05 pm
Registered user
on Oct 11, 2023 at 4:05 pm
@Noel
Never gonna happen. Israel is trying to write history in real time, and history is written by the victors. [Portion removed.]
Registered user
Stanford
on Oct 11, 2023 at 8:13 pm
Registered user
on Oct 11, 2023 at 8:13 pm
It is so good to see that turnout. Many of us are still reeling from the horrific attacks on citizens in their houses and at the music festival in Israel. Will never forget the images on TV and in the news--nor should any of us do so. I pray for the Jewish people in Israel, around the world, at home, and all the innocents in the region who will suffer in the aftermath.
Registered user
Professorville
on Oct 11, 2023 at 10:33 pm
Registered user
on Oct 11, 2023 at 10:33 pm
@Noel Your post contains misinformation
You got history wrong. In 1948 after the Brits retracted, the new Jewish state of Israel wanted piece. The declaration of independence called for equal rights to all religions, ethnicities, genders. But the Arabs in Israel and around it came to slaughter the Jews. Fortunately, Israel prevailed. Some Palestinians escaped because they feared the Jews would do to them what they planned to do to the Jews. Those that remained did very well and became contributing citizens in a flourishing liberal democracy.
Hamas had been controlling Gaza since 2005. Gaza is a beautiful piece of land with a long beach. Hamas could have turned Gaza into Singapore (or Tel Aviv) and borders would open into Egypt and Israel. But instead, they turned it into a terror hub. Hamas gained power in an election (by plurality not majority) in 2005, and that was the last election since. Their platform is to kill all Jews, eradicate Israel, and put extreme ISIS-style "Islamic Law." They do not care about own citizens. LGBTQ people in Gaza are being murdered and seek asylum in Israel.
The situation now is very delicate. My heart explodes with grief and also goes out to the civilians at Gaza. Israel has the right to defend itself against ISIS/Hamas. Containment had failed and Hamas must be disarmed and eradicated. Imagine San Jose was ISIS! Firing missiles and roaming home to home murdering families, raping, kidnapping. Would you tolerate that? Israel follows the exact same protocols of war as other western democracies: Every single operation is carefully vetted for (1) need and (2) proportionality and BOTH must be satisfied. Israel will not risk harming civilians to damage a store of hand guns. But they would to destroy a store of missiles to be directed at Israeli towns. Hamas cowards are hiding behind civilians.
Registered user
Midtown
on Oct 13, 2023 at 12:35 am
Registered user
on Oct 13, 2023 at 12:35 am
I mostly concur with "Greene and Paly Parent" but let's not completely whitewash Israel's responsibilities and failures.
Registered user
Another Palo Alto neighborhood
on Oct 13, 2023 at 6:43 am
Registered user
on Oct 13, 2023 at 6:43 am
Not directly related to this meeting, but I do have concerns about what is being discussed in our school classrooms about this. Social studies, history, current affairs, what is being taught about this in schools and how are our teachers coping with the questions asked by the students? Are these topics allowed to be discussed and is accurate information being taught?
Registered user
Professorville
on Oct 13, 2023 at 3:44 pm
Registered user
on Oct 13, 2023 at 3:44 pm
@EADGBE
Indeed, Israel is far from perfect, but so is the (current) US. There is work to do. What I described is the high level picture -- that the antisemitic disinformation campaigns that infiltrated both the extreme right and extreme left in the US, including schools and universities, completely lost sight of.
There is no equivalency. If Israel disarms, the Jews in Israel will be slaughtered. If Hamas (or anyone that attacked Israel) will disarm and commit to peace, everyone will thrive. This had been the situation for 75+ years and did not change.
Another misinformation is on displacement. Correct that some Palestinians left the teritory that became the Jewish state. But there was even more "displacement" the other way in the middle east of Jews from Arab-controlled areas into the Jewish state. The majority of Israel's 7M Jews have ancestry that mostly never ever left the Middle East (Those from Europe also originated from the land).
@Bystander As for PAUSD: An antisemitic "ethnic studies" curriculum was close to being adopted in the past. Students report that teachers sometimes express deeply misguided views as facts in class or avoid accurate teaching on historic and current events. The Superintendent messaging this week with many families in trauma was delayed and lacked empathy and substance. In contrast to neighboring MVLA, who echoed the President of the US. PAUSD needs to work on accurate matter-of-fact teaching of history and current events and creating an environment were all our students, including Jews and Muslim and everyone else, feel safe and supported.
Registered user
Crescent Park
on Oct 14, 2023 at 3:00 pm
Registered user
on Oct 14, 2023 at 3:00 pm
To Greene & Paly Parent
You clearly have not read any comprehensive histories of Israel/Palestine. At the beginning, Zionist leaders wanted as much land as possible with as few indigenous people as possible. They had been arming themselves for years and executed terror attacks against the British, notably blowing up the King David Hotel and against Palestinians, blowing up apartment buildings. When independence was declared they went on the offensive to grab more land and to scare off and/or drive out indigenous people. The Palestinians had no say whatsoever in the founding of a Jewish state in their midsts and they were well aware of the Zionist terror attacks and the rhetoric of Zionist leaders about not wanting non-Jews in the mix. But the Palestinians were largely unarmed and not organized so they were driven off their lands or the fled in the wake of the Deir Yassin massacre.
How can you be so naive as to believe that every Israeli bombing mission is "carefully vetted?" Israel was taken totally by surprise yet they started bombing right away. Their politicians were streaming for blood and the IDF delivered blood promptly. Have you read a single account of any of Israel's past attacks on Gaza written by people in Gaza at the time?
I strongly recommend you and everyone else on this stream subscribe to and actually read Haaretz to get a more complete picture of what is actually going on in Israel/Palestine. As Israel's enabler, there will not be peace until Americans who care about Israel know the truth about both sides of the story.
Registered user
Midtown
on Oct 15, 2023 at 2:01 pm
Registered user
on Oct 15, 2023 at 2:01 pm
I'm praying for both the people of Israel and the Palestinians. However, the Palestinians of Gaza need to stop supporting and defending Hamas terrorists who initiate conflict with atrocities. While various activists can complain about "Zionists" (and even use that word as a slur), I'd rather support those "Zionists" over those groups who either proactively massacre innocent civilians -- including babies, children and the elderly -- or support those who do.
I'll never forget seeing footage of Hamas supporters celebrating in the streets of Gaza when the twin towers of the World Trade Center fell in 2001. The footage of the celebrations is still available online. As a freshman in college, I found the celebration of the deaths of thousands of civilians to be grotesque and unconscionable. Yet, I've seen similar footage this week in marches around the world that support Hamas. It leaves that same sickening feeling in my stomach.
"Pray for the peace of Jerusalem. May those who love you be secure."
- Psalm 122:6
Registered user
Professorville
on Oct 16, 2023 at 9:50 am
Registered user
on Oct 16, 2023 at 9:50 am
@Noel
It is true that some Jewish resistance movements in Israel before the establishment of the state in 1948 tried to push the British out. This was at the time that Jews were slaughtered in Europe and the Brits were turning away fragile boats loaded with Jewish refugees and sending them back to their death by the Nazis. These non-main stream groups engaged in some limited violence ONLY against British soldiers NEVER against civilians.
During the same period, in the Middle East, many Palestinians and Arabs engaged in terrible violence against Jews. I know that. My own parents were Jewish children in Baghdad at the time. They were nearly slaughtered by a mob. BTW, both were saved by Muslim neighbors. Fortunately, the Jews in Israel had the means to protect themselves from similar attackes. Again, since biblical times, Jews never initiate terror against civilians. Never took any piece of land (purchased perhaps) before 1948. In 1948 and 1967 there were brutal attacks aimed to eliminate Israel and the Jews. As a consquence, Israel expanded territorially. Most of that land is now part of the Palestinian autonomy or back to Egypt, including much of what used to be Jewish populated land for millenia.
The value system starts with what school children are taught. I was educated in Israeli schools, and we were taught to value peace, co-existence, life. That we take THE HIGH ROAD on the face of the most atrocious terrorism against children, as we were learning to be alert of bombs and terrorists. In contrast, children in the Palestinian autonomies schools, in Hamas-controlled Gaza but even in the West Bank autonomy, are taught to hate, endorse the slaughter of civilians, martrydom by slaughter and death, and alternative history.